Free Will they say. But really?

free will sqFollowing a lecture on Subjectivity presented by Wellesley Binding (a master mind and artist) I was asked to comment on in my blog, any thoughts that came up for me. The after thought that continues to linger in my mind is the concept of free will.  I find myself asking: For a society of free people, why do I still feel so caught up and influenced by what society dictates and readily determines for me?  Is the concept of free will all but an illusion?

Freedom of thought, thankfully in the country I live in, is permitted. However, I still will most likely be judged and discriminated for my opinions and beliefs, which somewhat squashes the pleasure and feelings of liberation that I may have experienced when expressing such notions.  I believe that I am led to assume that I am free to make my own choices, however certain circumstances are set in place to ensure that I have a pretty hard time doing so.  Do I embark upon a career in this or that? Where in the world shall I live? What food shall I buy this week for my meals? Which self-help book or workshop should I enroll in this month?

In this century, it has become possible to choose from an array of alternatives, satisfying our human need to have free will. However, I am left thinking that it would have been simpler (and certainly less confusing) if when a few hundred years ago, my life was pre-determined by the circumstances that I was born into.  I would have lived in the place where I was born.  I would have followed in my foremothers footsteps. I would have eaten whatever was growing in my garden or whatever I could have traded for my crops. If my roof needed fixing, my neighbours would help me fix it.  I would belong to the religion of my forebears.  I would be betrothed to the boy next door. I would go to the only healer of the village, and be advised of how to heal my aliments and when to be initiated by the spiritual ‘quest’.  Apart from marrying the boy next door (whom I’m sure would have been a great hunter at least), I think I would have been pretty happy with my lot of determined fate!


6 thoughts on “Free Will they say. But really?

  1. stephenayers42 says:

    “Life is but a plethora of decisions and, consequently, the results from our decisions. It’s really as simple as that. Such is the nature of beings with free will.” I write about free will often. It’s an interesting topic and concept.


  2. alwayscon says:

    ” satisfying our human need to have free will.”
    I think that the will to be free is more important than Free Will itself.
    I have a hard time believing that as humans, we have Free Will. Seems to me that the decisions we make, even though we may think they are free, are unconsciously determined by many surrounding factors. Ideas and even thoughts seem to be caused by stimuli.
    It’s just that these days there are many alternatives compared to back then, so as you said, our will to be free is satisfied.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s